Federation Vs. Empire: The Breakdown

Although both sides have advantages over the other I'm going to have to say that in a fleet battle the Federation would defeat the Empire. The Empire's ships are big, slow, and are not designed for ship to ship interstellar combat. Their main purposes are to carry troops across the galaxy as well as to carry fighter squadrons to various rebel hotspots. They are out matched in fire power as well as in range. Their shielding generated from vulnerable exterior shield domes that can be destroyed easily. Also once an Imperial ship's bridge is destroyed it is a sitting duck. As far as the fighter squadrons are concerned they would have very little affect on the shields of the Federation ships due to their very limited power. They would end up being target practice for the Federation's advanced targeting computers. Also another fact that cannot be ignored is the fact that the largest fleet the Empire has ever been known to assemble was 27 ships, this is small compared to the number of ships the Federation has been known to mass for their armadas.

However, in a direct war between the Galactic Empire and the United Federation of Planets I believe the empire would win hands down. The reason is in the logistics. The area controlled by the Empire is proportionately a lot larger than that controlled by the Federation so therefore the Empire has lot more resources available to it. If there was a war the Empire (if they were smart enough to) could simply massively outproduce the Federation and defeat them by shear numbers alone.
I have researched this extensively and this is what I think would happen. If anyone has any other theories or thoughts please leave them. Isn't crossing science fiction universes fun!








